Miami Real Estate vs Orange County: What $2 Million Really Buys

If you are weighing Miami against Orange County with about $2 million to spend, the same money buys a completely different kind of ownership on each coast.

Square footage will not tell you which one gives you more. The lifestyle you want will.

That sounds like a dodge until you put the listings side by side. Then it stops being one, because the numbers are far closer than almost every California buyer expects, and the differences that actually matter sit in places a price per square foot calculation never reaches: who maintains the building, what your insurance costs, whether you can lock the door in May and open it again in November, and whether you want a yard at all.

The short answer

At roughly $2 million, Orange County buys more private square footage inside a residential neighborhood. Miami buys newer construction and a service model where the building takes care of itself while you are somewhere else.

Neither one is the better deal in the abstract. The better one is whichever matches the problem you are solving.

Our position, after watching Orange County owners shop Florida for the past two years: if you are buying in Miami to recreate what you already own in Newport Beach or Irvine, you will probably be disappointed. If you are buying because you want something your Orange County house cannot give you, a view, a short walk to dinner, no pool to drain, no gardener to schedule, you will probably be happy. The disappointed ones are almost always the buyers who shopped for size.

What the listings actually show

These are the properties compared in the video. Prices were current at the time of filming.

Read the Irvine and Brickell rows again. That is roughly 794 fewer square feet for about $101,000 more. You are not giving up half the space to live in Miami, which is what most people assume before they look.

The square footage myth

California buyers arrive in Florida with a price per square foot number in their head and try to shop with it. It does not transfer.

In Irvine, square footage is close to the whole product. A master planned community sells you a floor plan, a lot, a school district and a street, and the comparison between two houses two blocks apart really does come down to feet and condition. In a Brickell tower it is one line on a much longer list. What floor. Which exposure. How the association is funded and what it holds in reserve. Whether the pool deck and the gym were refreshed in the last five years. Two residences with identical floor plans in the same building can be worth very different money, and the floor plan will not tell you which is which.

The same problem exists closer to home, it just wears different clothes. The rooms that go dark at four in the afternoon never show up in the square footage of an Orange County listing either. They show up in the offers.

What the price does not show

A few cost lines move when you buy in Florida instead of California, and the obvious one is the smallest.

Insurance is the line people underestimate. Association dues in a service building are the line people forget to annualize, because a monthly number reads as small until you multiply it by twelve. And property taxes work differently depending on whether the home is your permanent residence, because Florida's homestead exemption applies, in the state's own words, "when someone owns property and makes it his or her permanent residence." A second home does not qualify.

The California side matters more than the Florida side for most of the people we talk to, because it decides whether this is a second home or a move. The Franchise Tax Board is blunt about the difference. Its 2025 Guidelines for Determining Resident Status, FTB Publication 1031, state that "Residents of California are taxed on ALL income, including income from sources outside California," while "Nonresidents of California are taxed only on income from California sources." Buying a residence in Brickell does not change your residency by itself. Your CPA, rather than your agent, is the person to ask what would.

Start with the problem you are solving

If you already own a large home in Orange County, do you want to recreate that in Miami?

Maybe you do. Some of our clients want the same square footage and a yard for the dogs, and they find it in a single family neighborhood rather than in a tower. Others realise, about four properties in, that what they wanted was a view and a door they could lock in May. Those two buyers should not be shown the same inventory, and showing them the same inventory is the most common mistake we see in this market. If you are earlier in the thinking than that, our walkthrough on moving to Miami from California covers the ground before the listings, and the comparison of The Well Coconut Grove and Bay Harbor Islands goes deeper on those two buildings than this post does.

The purchase price does not tell the whole story and neither does the square footage. Strategy comes before the property.

Before you register with any developer

Registering your name on a Florida new construction project can assign you to that developer's own sales team, which quietly removes your representation from the transaction. Do these four things first.

1. Settle the California question. Find out what your Orange County property is worth today and what it would actually net after costs, before you commit to a number in Florida.
2. Get a full year of carrying cost in writing. Association dues, insurance, taxes at the rate that applies without a homestead exemption, and any club or wellness membership the building requires.
3. Ask who represents you, in writing, before you tour. If you register directly with a developer, find out whether you can still bring your own broker and what that answer costs you.
4. Read the reserve study and the association budget. In a service building those two documents predict your future costs far better than the finish level of the model unit does.

The last one is the step people skip. It is also the one that costs money later.

Talk to Paula before you tour

If you own in Orange County and you are considering Miami as a second home or a future move, Paula Aragone's free Orange County to Miami Guide walks through the neighborhoods, the new construction, the service buildings and the questions to ask before you register with any developer. The California half of the decision is the half she handles, and it is usually the half that decides the rest. If you are weighing whether to keep the Orange County house at all, our piece on buying a second home in Miami without leaving California is the companion to this one.

Paula Aragone

Paula has spent 23 years in Orange County real estate, with more than 900 transactions and over $900 million in sales behind her. She holds the CPRES, SRES, Certified Luxury, Certified REO and Certified Relocation designations, and her law school background shapes how she handles the paperwork side of a sale. She works with sellers and buyers across Newport Beach, Irvine, Corona del Mar, Huntington Beach and the rest of Orange County.

Full bio | Instagram | LinkedIn