The Well Coconut Grove vs The Well Bay Harbor Islands: Same Brand, Two Different Lives

The Well Coconut Grove and The Well Bay Harbor Islands share the same developer, the same architect, and the same wellness brand, and they sit just 12 miles apart in Miami. One is finished, move in ready, and down to single digit availability. The other delivers in 2028 and offers first pick of 192 residences. They are not competing for the same buyer, and knowing which one you are is the entire decision.

I am Paula Aragone with Aragone & Associates. Over 23 years my team and I have completed more than 900 transactions and over 200 relocations for clients across Southern California, and I own property on Bay Harbor Islands myself. Here is how I walk California buyers through these two buildings.

What Is The Well In Coconut Grove?

The Well Coconut Grove is Miami's first wellness residences project in the Grove: 192 residences across 8 floors, built around a wellness club of more than 13,000 square feet with a hyperbaric chamber, a communal bathhouse, functional medicine and IV therapy, and a staffed rooftop pool with physicians, nutritionists, and trainers on site. This is not a gym in the lobby. It is a building designed so that wellness is part of how you live in it daily.

Floor plans run from about 1,000 square feet up to 4,100, including lofts and townhome style residences at street level, and every layout gets a private balcony and full height glass. Select residences include something that does not exist at the Bay Harbor sister building: a wellness den, an extra room you define yourself as a longevity den, a mindful den, a mobility den, or simply an office.

The defining fact is the calendar. The building delivers in 2028, which means committing capital to a residence that does not physically exist yet. For some buyers that is the entire appeal, because they get first pick of the floor plan book and the chance to build equity while the building rises. For others it is an immediate no. Both reactions are correct. They just belong to different buyers.

The Well Bay Harbor Islands: Finished And Nearly Gone

Twelve miles north, on two small islands between the mainland and the beaches next to Bal Harbour, the sister building is complete. Buyers have already moved in. There are 66 residences on 8 levels with more than 22,000 square feet of wellness space, architecture by Arquitectonica, and wellness built into the residences themselves: therapeutic soaking tubs, red light therapy, reverse osmosis water, aromatherapy, and air purification as standards, not upgrades. Downstairs there is a caldarium, a saunarium, halotherapy steam, a cold plunge, and a reading room.

Because the building exists, everything about it is real today. You can walk the actual residence in the actual light at the hour you care about. The carrying costs are real numbers, not projections. One detail worth noticing: the building's office floors are nearly fully leased, and one tenant is said to be Tom Brady's family office. Make of that what you want, but it tells you who has been quietly looking at this building.

The catch is just as real. Finished means what is left is what is left. Residences start at $1,495,000 for a one bedroom of about 1,029 square feet and run to $3,850,000 for the largest layout still available, around 2,700 square feet. Availability is down to single digits. You are not choosing from a floor plan book anymore. You are choosing from what nobody else has taken.

The Well Coconut Grove vs The Well Bay Harbor Islands At A Glance

Put the two side by side and the differences stop being abstract. This is the comparison I sketch out for clients on the first call, before anyone books a flight.

Is The Well Coconut Grove Expensive?

The honest answer is that the purchase price is the least interesting number. Pre construction pricing moves as buildings sell through, so current pricing is exactly the kind of thing to confirm on a live call with the developer's team rather than trust to an article. The number I push clients to understand instead is what it costs to hold, not to buy: HOA fees, taxes, insurance, and management.

Property taxes in particular deserve a real look rather than a guess, since Florida assesses on a county basis and your bill follows the assessed value and the local millage rates published by the Miami-Dade County Property Appraiser. That office is the authoritative source for how a Miami residence will actually be assessed, and it is worth reading before you build a budget around a brochure. At Bay Harbor those carrying numbers exist today because the building exists. At the Grove they are projections until delivery. If your financial plan needs certainty, that difference matters more than any brochure figure.

Is Coconut Grove A Rich Part Of Miami?

Coconut Grove Miami is one of the city's oldest and most established neighborhoods, and it feels like it: tree canopy over the streets, the bay at the end of the road, a marina, and an actual walkable village where people live year round. It is not a strip that people visit and leave. That is what makes it fundamentally different from the Bay Harbor experience, which is a quiet island you come home to. Same wellness brand, completely different life. One is an island you arrive at. The other is a neighborhood you join.

My Orange County clients tend to sort themselves quickly once I frame it that way. The buyer coming out of a Corona del Mar village block, used to walking to coffee and running into three people they know, almost always leans Coconut Grove. The buyer leaving a gated street in Newport Coast or a quiet canyon lot above Laguna Beach usually wants the island. And the Irvine family that has spent fifteen years optimizing for schools and predictability tends to care most about the delivery calendar, because a 2028 handover has to line up with a school year to make any sense at all.

Move In Now Or Wait: How Miami Pre Construction Condos Compare

Four questions decide this, and they are the same whether you are relocating out of California full time, buying a second home for the winter months, or evaluating a future investment. If you are earlier in the process and still weighing the move itself rather than the building, start with my breakdown of moving to Miami from California, then come back to this comparison.

1. When do you need to be there? If the answer is this year, the Grove is out. That is not a preference, that is your calendar.
2. How picky are you? Bay Harbor is down to single digits while the Grove is still an entire menu, and if you care which direction your windows face, that matters more than any amenity list.
3. What is the property actually for? A lock and leave second home, a future full time residence, a place where family gathers, and an investment are different purchases, and Miami pre construction condos serve some of those jobs far better than others.
4. Do you want to arrive somewhere quiet, or somewhere alive? This is the one that usually decides it in about three seconds.

Where I Stand, And Why I Will Not Pick For You

I own on Bay Harbor Islands. I have bought there more than once with my own money, from the builder at the beginning and as finished product at the end, so I am not neutral about that island and I will not pretend to be. I know what it is like at seven in the morning and I know what it is like in August. And I also know that if I were choosing again with a different life, I might land somewhere else entirely. You cannot decide this from a video or an article, including this one. Two buildings 12 miles apart, and they feel nothing alike. Fifteen minutes standing inside each one will tell you what photographs cannot.

See Both Buildings In One Trip

Go soon, because the timing is not symmetrical. The Grove will still be there in six months. Bay Harbor, at single digit availability, might not.

Here is how I make it simple. You start with a private call with me and the developer's team, so you get current availability, real pricing, and your actual questions answered before you ever get on a plane. Then a private tour of both buildings, arranged back to back in one trip, same day if you can manage it, so the comparison is still fresh when you are standing in the second one. I own on that island and have done this trip many times, so you also get my personal list of where to stay, where to eat, and which neighborhoods to drive through. And if you are selling a California property to make the move happen, whether that is a house in Newport Beach or a condo further inland, tell me on that call, because lining up those two transactions is the hardest part of the entire move, and that is exactly what my team does.

Start here: The Well Miami.

Paula Aragone

Paula leads Aragone & Associates in Newport Beach with 23 years in the business, more than 900 transactions, and over $900 million in sales. She holds the CPRES, SRES, Certified Luxury, Certified REO, and Certified Relocation designations, brings a law school background to complicated transactions, and has personally guided more than 200 relocations. She also owns property on Bay Harbor Islands, which is why clients moving between Southern California and Miami tend to call her first.

Full Bio  |  Instagram  |  LinkedIn