
What Is the 90 Percent Rule in a California Probate Sale?
By Paula Aragone, CPRES. Updated
In a court confirmed probate sale, the offer must be at least 90 percent of the appraised value. It is a floor that protects the estate, and it does not apply to every sale.
Probate Code sections 10309 and 10503.

A Floor for Court Confirmed Sales
Under Probate Code section 10309, a private sale of estate real property cannot be confirmed by the court unless the offer is at least 90 percent of the appraised value, and both the appraisal and its valuation date are within one year before the confirmation hearing. It does not apply to a sale made under authority of the Independent Administration of Estates Act.
On a home appraised at $1,000,000, the lowest offer a court could confirm in a private sale is $900,000. Nothing in the rule stops the price from going higher, and overbids at the hearing often push it up.
If the appraisal is out of date, or the court is satisfied it is too high or too low, a new appraisal can be made before the sale or the confirmation.
Answer reviewed November 17, 2026What the Rule Means for a Sale
It protects the estate
A court will not confirm a private sale far below the appraised value.
It is not a target
The rule sets the lowest price a court can confirm, not the price to aim for.
Watch the appraisal date
An appraisal older than a year before the hearing must be updated.
Know your authority
Under full IAEA authority the rule does not apply, and neither does confirmation.

The Text Behind the Rule
The rule is short, and its exceptions matter as much as the rule. These are the provisions to read with it.
Your attorney confirms which ones apply to your estate.
The rule
No private sale of real property is confirmed unless the offer is at least 90 percent of an appraisal made, and valued, within one year before the confirmation hearing.
Probate Code section 10309(a)A new appraisal
A new appraisal may be made when the last one is too old or when the court is satisfied it is too high or too low.
Probate Code section 10309(b)Not under the IAEA
The 90 percent requirement does not apply when the personal representative sells under the Independent Administration of Estates Act.
Probate Code section 10503Overbids above the floor
At the hearing, a written offer at least 10 percent more on the first $10,000 and 5 percent more above that can be accepted, with the court keeping discretion to order a new sale.
Probate Code section 10311
General real estate information, not legal or tax advice. The estate's attorney decides which procedure applies to your sale.

Working With the 90 Percent Rule
Check the appraisal date
Make sure it falls within a year of the expected hearing.
Price above the floor
Use comparables and condition, not 90 percent, to set the list price.
Market for competition
More buyers before the hearing means a stronger confirmed price.
Ask about IAEA authority
With full authority, the rule and the hearing do not apply.
“Just as importantly, Paula understands how to work within the professional team surrounding an estate. She communicates effectively with fiduciaries, attorneys, beneficiaries, and other advisors, and she understands the importance of transparency, documentation, and keeping everyone informed throughout the process.”
Diana Meinhold
Professional fiduciary. Google review
Questions About the 90 Percent Rule
What is the 90 percent rule in California probate?
A private sale of estate real property cannot be confirmed by the court unless the offer is at least 90 percent of the appraised value, using an appraisal made and valued within one year before the confirmation hearing (Probate Code section 10309).
Does the 90 percent rule apply to every probate sale?
No. It applies to private sales that need court confirmation. It does not apply to a sale made under authority of the Independent Administration of Estates Act (Probate Code section 10503).
What if the market has dropped since the appraisal?
A new appraisal may be made before the sale or confirmation when the court is satisfied the latest appraisal is too high or too low, or when it is more than a year old (Probate Code section 10309(b)).
Is 90 percent of the appraisal a good price for a probate house?
It is only the minimum a court will confirm. Our own estate sales have closed well above the first cash offers the families were given, because competition, not the floor, set the price.
- Selling above the referee's appraisal →
- Probate overbid calculator →
- The date of death appraisal →
- IAEA full vs limited authority →
- Probate Real Estate →
- Do Probate Homes Sell Below Market? →
- Probate Terms and Definitions →
- Probate Help in Irvine →
- Probate Help in Huntington Beach →

Aim Well Above the Floor
(949) 415-4784Send Paula the appraisal and the address and she will show you where the market is likely to land, not just the 90 percent line. No cost and no obligation.
Request a ConsultationPaula Aragone, CA DRE #01364746. Aragone & Associates | First Team Real Estate, CA DRE #01008773. 4 Corporate Plaza Dr #100, Newport Beach, CA 92660. Results reflect individual properties and the market at the time of sale; outcomes vary. General real estate information, not legal or tax advice. Consult the estate's attorney about fiduciary duties and authority.
